In the midst of everything I’ve been going through lately, thank you for reminding me why I started a blog…
This is a beautiful and timely response to receive to my long-running 10 Questions About Your Feminist Parenthood from Slow Growing.
(Can you believe that my 10 Questions have been going since 2007, have received a couple of hundred responses from all over the world from all kinds of feminist parents, and have by now, also been published by me in an academic book?)
5. Do you ever feel compromised as a feminist mother? Do you ever feel you’ve failed as a feminist mother?
The moments when I feel like I have failed most are when I haven’t done my best to act in solidarity with another mother; whether that be by listening well to a friend who is tired in her parenting, or supporting another mother in a tough situation in public, or by finding an authentic response to the suffering of women in other places. I feel this failure daily but I know that for me, and the work of feminism in itself, there will always be work to do and mistakes to be made–it’s a big world out there to respond to. So there’s got to be grace as well. Ultimately the work of feminism is a uniting work, one that illuminates and works through–and for–our deep inter-connectedness and dependence on one another. When I lose sight of that, that is when I feel I have failed the most.
6. Has identifying as a feminist mother ever been difficult? Why?
In the circles that I move in it can be difficult identifying as a feminist–this is mostly because I am not sure that my definition of feminism necessarily fits with the definition in other people’s heads. I think many people still think that feminism equates to hating men, or thinking that you have to run a successful corporation… but as you can see, this is nothing like my feminism.
Through my partner’s workplace and through our church life, I meet a lot of women from more conservative backgrounds who are often at home with their kids too. I wonder if they feel marginalised enough by the celebrity/corporate type of feminism, so much so that they choose not to identify with feminism altogether. I don’t know. I just know that I often feel misunderstood by this group, and misunderstood by some successful working mothers who don’t see the value of the care work I do, or the complexities of professional, cultural, and financial systems that make it hard for many mothers to work outside the home. However, it is never so difficult that I don’t identify as a feminist.
There’s a lot in this response that I relate to, but particularly, her thoughts on vulnerability and connectedness. I love this latest reply to my questions, and thank you for keeping the 10 questions alive.
(You can find all the many other responses in this series here. If you’d like to respond to these questions yourself you can either email me your answers and I’ll put them on blue milk as a guest post or you can post them elsewhere and let me know and I’ll link to them).
“The moments when I feel like I have failed most are when I haven’t done my best to act in solidarity with another mother”, wow can I ever relate to that! And I feel like it applies to my sense of feminism more broadly: I am definitely filled with a sense of disappointment in myself when I fail to live up to my own standards of solidarity with other women. Unrelated: this post reminded me that I once filled out these questions, so I’m off to see if I saved the word document (because the blog is long gone) because I’m curious how my answers may have changed through some pretty intense experiences and major changes in my life and the political atmosphere over the last 5 years.
I’m so glad to see these still cropping up! And yes, this piece about failing as a feminist mother – “The moments when I feel like I have failed most are when I haven’t done my best to act in solidarity with another mother” – I feel that; it’s so real. I’m not always convinced that I owe it to other mothers to support their every decision, but the times when I could have and didn’t stick with me.